Why does everyone love Jeff? He's insane and kills people for fun. I'm not trying to be a hater, Jeff's one of my favorite Creepypasta characters and I think that he's great, but seriously, would YOU want to date a psychopath in real life? Just asking.
Here's how I see it, in the minds of those fan girls that claim to "love" Jeff, they don't see how truly insane he is. All these pictures of Jeff don't show the real thing and because of this these fan girls find him cute. But if they came face to face with him, if they saw his carved and jagged smile, his burnt eyes and bleached leathery skin, not to mention the sharp cold, probably developing rust, knife at their necks ready to slice it open, do you think they would still love him? Would they still find him beautiful? These are just pictures not the real thing. In fact this is just sugar coating a lie! Jeff is truly my favorite creepypasta and from all these lovey dovey pictures and stories it kind of makes me upset. Jeff isn't like this. But because of the pictures and fanfics, our minds have erased his real looks and replaced him with these. Let me ask you something: how many pictures have you seen of the original one? Or at least ones that depict his real self?
And yes, just in case you ask, "But you don't know how insane he is" Yes I do know. He's a sadistic psychopath who would kill anyone regardless of their pleas and begging, and would kill them in the most goriest, bloodiest, way possible. But hey, liking him for his insanity is just my preference.
Yeah, fans portray him quite nicely, but we have to remember that he isn't like that. And our minds want us to believe he is, but he's not. The pictures are cute and all, but we can't let our minds get sucked into a fantasy that isn't real.